As I pointed out in post #33, cable 1 is the issue and confirmed by your running of the channel tests subsequently. Before you risk climbing ladders etc., have you very carefully checked the F-plug at the receiver end? Ensure the braid is shiny (not corroded) and that there are no stray wisps of braid that could be touching the centre conductor. Any sign of corrosion at the receiver end of the cable would indicate that water has got in from outside and has travelled downwards.
If all is ok at the receiver end, then you will have to check at the LNB, or get a professional to re-make the connections. I generally use silicone grease (a completely different substance to silicone sealant!) to waterproof the F-plugs at the LNB. Silicone grease is similar in texture to Vaseline and remains greasy and waterproof on electrical and RF connectors for years.